Figure most people aren't stumbling across this film for a Saturday night date movie, and that most people know what they're getting here. So, I made it a point to watch this within a couple weeks of seeing Margin Call, and thought Too Big To Fail was much better in comparison for a number of reasons.
The acting here is top notch. A paid cable movie that was able to snag a feature film cast. Specifically, Paul Giamatti and William Hurt are worth watching in and of themselves. Any actor who can make you feel bad for Hank Paulson for even five minutes deserves a golf clap in your living room.
I also appreciate the depth in this movie. A lot of that credit likely goes to the author whose book it was based on. Please don't misunderstand my praise for the movie. I certainly have complaints with certain portrayals, but there are plenty of documentaries on the topic, so if you're going to bang on the film for the reality it creates, I think you misunderstand the general concept of film. With that caveat, this movie is far more detailed and complete in its depiction than Margin Call, for example.
It reminds me, not surprisingly, quite a bit of Recount in its storytelling structure. It's a delicate challenge to dramatize a non fiction work with material this dense. There aren't exactly a lot of guns and explosions, and extra weight falls on the actors, editing, production and so forth. Merely holding your interest with a movie like this is a challenge and they pull it off rather effortlessly.
Finally, this movie makes the prudent decision to play the characters fairly straight in my mind. This telling of the story rings more true because the filmmakers largely eschew transparent attempts to force empathy for the protagonists. It doesn't matter if you like these people because you're fascinated by them and their moment in history. Not a perfect movie, but it's a quality addition to an important conversation.
The biggest complaint I've heard about both films is the notion that the criminals, swindlers, and greedy bastards who populate them are far too often protrayed sympathetically or even heroically. In theory, I don't even disagree. The problem is you are far less likely to watch a film about folks you have a burning hatred for. This wasn't filmed by a documentary crew, but it is a movie with a message. In the end, it's a not a question of whether this film storms the right castle with enough pitchforks. It's way more simple than that. All that matters in this context is whether it tells a good story, and I think it absolutely does.
4/5
Watch or Skip
P.S. These reviews are a snapshot of how I feel about a movie immediately after watching it. I have a feeling that had I seen this one first, I would have downgraded Margin Call a little more. I'd still give it a mild "Watch", but if you've only got time for one, go with Too Big To Fail, hands down.
Wednesday, September 19, 2012
Beginners
Expected to like this much more than I did, and in large part maybe that's why it gets two stars instead of three: expectations.
I'll also take a large chunk of the blame for going in with misconceptions about how the film was structured. I'm aware that he won for SUPPORTING actor, but I still wanted more Christopher Plummer. To me, that was basically the redeemable part of the film. I had little to no interest in the cliched indie movie romance between the son and girlfriend, which was essentially depicted in a series of movie shorts that result in no personal growth, numerous sad faces, and occasional bright moments brought to you by the scene stealing dog. Just for fun, toss in a dying father as the undercurrent for the whole movie. I was ready for that part, but it turned out the movie wasn't good enough for me to want to deal with the general black cloud that comes with it.
It's a unique film, and I'm more than happy it got the recognition it did. No complaints about the Plummer Oscar. Again, maybe it's on me that I expected a different film, and it's possible that someone who knows exactly what they are getting can appreciate it more as a simple autobiographical adaptation. In the end, I just found the experiences of a newly out old man far more interesting than the generic angst of his kid, and sadly the balance of those two storylines was entirely backwards.
2/5
Watch or Skip
I'll also take a large chunk of the blame for going in with misconceptions about how the film was structured. I'm aware that he won for SUPPORTING actor, but I still wanted more Christopher Plummer. To me, that was basically the redeemable part of the film. I had little to no interest in the cliched indie movie romance between the son and girlfriend, which was essentially depicted in a series of movie shorts that result in no personal growth, numerous sad faces, and occasional bright moments brought to you by the scene stealing dog. Just for fun, toss in a dying father as the undercurrent for the whole movie. I was ready for that part, but it turned out the movie wasn't good enough for me to want to deal with the general black cloud that comes with it.
It's a unique film, and I'm more than happy it got the recognition it did. No complaints about the Plummer Oscar. Again, maybe it's on me that I expected a different film, and it's possible that someone who knows exactly what they are getting can appreciate it more as a simple autobiographical adaptation. In the end, I just found the experiences of a newly out old man far more interesting than the generic angst of his kid, and sadly the balance of those two storylines was entirely backwards.
2/5
Watch or Skip
Tuesday, September 4, 2012
Margin Call
Being honest with myself, I think I like this movie better in theory than in practice. Along those same lines, I also like it more in the context of a social commentary, than as a stand alone film in a vaccumn.
It's well acted and any dialouge junkie will find numerous poignant speeches and quips that cut to the heart of the matter and nudge it off the fence into quite watchable territory. That said, there's a nagging feeling of empty calories here, which is odd given the weighty subject matter. It sometimes feels like the indie equivalent of great novel rushed into blockbuster production to capitalize on a hot topic. It also will be mildly distracting/problematic for some that essentially the whole movie takes place at the office. Of course, that's no biggie, since action verbs don't really exist in this film. It's like Phone Booth, only with numbers and fancy suits.
Perhaps, this works better as a companion piece with Too Big to Fail than either movie does on it's own. That's on my list as well, and I'll try to watch it soon to have some comparison. Maybe, I'm just pissed that the bankers come across as a little too sympathetic. It was a little too convienent for me, that nearly EVERY character shifts seamlessly from blissfully selfish to profoundly conflicted on a dime.
In the end, this review is a bit of a contradiction. It's largely negative in it's detail, but in totality, I think it's worth a watch. The issue is too important to ignore, and there are several moments of five star dialouge. It's just that this particular telling of the story is a bit disappointing and most of the best stuff would have worked equally well as an audiobook.
3/5 stars
Watch or Skip
It's well acted and any dialouge junkie will find numerous poignant speeches and quips that cut to the heart of the matter and nudge it off the fence into quite watchable territory. That said, there's a nagging feeling of empty calories here, which is odd given the weighty subject matter. It sometimes feels like the indie equivalent of great novel rushed into blockbuster production to capitalize on a hot topic. It also will be mildly distracting/problematic for some that essentially the whole movie takes place at the office. Of course, that's no biggie, since action verbs don't really exist in this film. It's like Phone Booth, only with numbers and fancy suits.
Perhaps, this works better as a companion piece with Too Big to Fail than either movie does on it's own. That's on my list as well, and I'll try to watch it soon to have some comparison. Maybe, I'm just pissed that the bankers come across as a little too sympathetic. It was a little too convienent for me, that nearly EVERY character shifts seamlessly from blissfully selfish to profoundly conflicted on a dime.
In the end, this review is a bit of a contradiction. It's largely negative in it's detail, but in totality, I think it's worth a watch. The issue is too important to ignore, and there are several moments of five star dialouge. It's just that this particular telling of the story is a bit disappointing and most of the best stuff would have worked equally well as an audiobook.
3/5 stars
Watch or Skip
The American
I actually considered giving this movie a third star, but I realized that was
just the power of Clooney. I found this film visually striking but otherwise
lacking. It makes for a wonderful Italian postcard.
Mildly shameful admission: I fast fowarded through many of the silent portions, making the movie far more watchable. I would have been much more bored and downgraded it further as a more static theater experience.
That says it all I think. Clooney is never bad, and I actually enjoyed him in a more understated performance. The problem was the whole movie was just a notch TOO mellow given the subject matter. Kudos for not going with a more traditional shoot 'em up script. The problem is the decision to couple that with such an old fashioned and predictable character arc and ending. This combination lends an overall flatness to the whole thing. Absolutely pleasant, but utterly forgettable.
2/5 stars
Watch or Skip
Mildly shameful admission: I fast fowarded through many of the silent portions, making the movie far more watchable. I would have been much more bored and downgraded it further as a more static theater experience.
That says it all I think. Clooney is never bad, and I actually enjoyed him in a more understated performance. The problem was the whole movie was just a notch TOO mellow given the subject matter. Kudos for not going with a more traditional shoot 'em up script. The problem is the decision to couple that with such an old fashioned and predictable character arc and ending. This combination lends an overall flatness to the whole thing. Absolutely pleasant, but utterly forgettable.
2/5 stars
Watch or Skip
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)